The Daily Breakdown takes a closer look at Intercontinental Exchange as shares tumble lower despite steady growth expectations.
Interested in more Deep Dive content? Check out our latest research.
Deep Dive
Many investors may not be familiar with Intercontinental Exchange, but they have likely heard of its prized possession: the New York Stock Exchange. While the NYSE is perhaps the company’s most famous asset, ICE is much more than a stock exchange operator.
The company also runs global exchanges, clearing houses, market-data services, fixed-income platforms and mortgage technology tools. Its reach spans futures and options tied to energy, agriculture, metals, rates, currencies and equities — including Brent crude futures, one of the world’s key oil benchmarks — making ICE a major piece of financial market infrastructure.
While ICE got off to a strong start this year, it and its peers were briefly swept up in the so-called “SaaSpocalypse” trade — the concern that AI could disrupt software, payments and, apparently, even exchange businesses.
The latest selloff does not appear to be driven by those same SaaS-related worries, but Intercontinental Exchange has not been alone. CME Group and Cboe Global Markets have also come under significant pressure. So how does that compare with the underlying business? Let’s take a look.
Future Growth Projections
In the world of exchange operators, volatility equals volume and volume equals profit. So the more recent low-volatility environment may explain some of the weakness that has come into play for this group, even though the business remains relatively healthy. Earnings trends for ICE over the last one, three and six months have increased by 0.9%, 6.1%, and 8.5%, respectively.
According to Bloomberg, analysts project the following:
- Earnings Growth: 17% in 2026, 8.6% in 2027, and 10.3% in 2028
- Revenue Growth: 10.4% in 2026, 4.9% in 2027, and 5.6% in 2028
Analysts currently have a consensus price target of ~$199 on ICE stock, implying about 44% upside to today’s stock price.
Want to receive these insights straight to your inbox?
Diving Deeper — Valuation
When we dissect the valuation over the last 10 years, we can see that the forward P/E ratio tends to trough at around 17.5 times earnings and hit a ceiling around 25 times. Now near the lower end of that range, bulls are wondering if the stock will find valuation support.
A declining stock price is one way to bring the valuation down, but as earnings expectations are on the rise — remember, the P/E ratio is “price” divided by “earnings” — that helps bring the valuation down even more quickly. However, that doesn’t mean that the stock will necessarily bottom just because the valuation has come down so quickly.
Risks
Risks for ICE include both market-wide and company-specific factors: A calmer market backdrop could weigh on trading and hedging activity, while weaker energy, rates, credit or equity volumes could pressure its exchange and clearing businesses. ICE also faces cybersecurity and operational risks given its role in market infrastructure, and competition from other exchanges, data providers and trading platforms. More specifically, its mortgage technology business remains tied to housing and lending activity, while its fixed-income and data units could be vulnerable to pricing pressure, client budget cuts or slower demand.
The Bottom Line
ICE’s pullback could be creating a more compelling setup, particularly as the stock trades near the lower end of its historical valuation range while earnings expectations continue to rise. Its diversified mix of exchanges, clearing, data, fixed income and mortgage technology gives it multiple levers for long-term growth.
That said, this is not a risk-free dip. Lower volatility can weigh on trading volumes, mortgage technology remains tied to housing activity, and competitive, regulatory and cybersecurity risks are always part of the equation. For bulls, the question is whether the recent weakness reflects a temporary reset — or a warning that growth expectations may need to cool.
Disclaimer:
Please note that due to market volatility, some of the prices may have already been reached and scenarios played out.